CFA Library

Stop Breathing for Oxygen. Start Training Your CO2 Tolerance.

4 min read · Sep 22, 2026

A person practicing a calm, controlled outdoor breathing exercise

We've all been taught to think about breathing during a workout the same way: suck in more air, get more oxygen, go harder. It's intuitive, and it's also not quite the thing that's actually limiting you.

I picked this up properly after reading James Nestor's book Breath and then hearing it laid out for training specifically on a recent episode of The Aerobic Edge podcast with Zack Kramer, "Why 'Breathe More Oxygen' Is a Myth: Nasal Breathing, CO2 Tolerance & the Diaphragm." Both make the same core point: for almost everyone, oxygen isn't the scarce resource during exercise. Your blood is already close to fully saturated with oxygen even mid-WOD. What actually caps your performance is how well your body handles carbon dioxide.

Why CO2 tolerance, not oxygen, is the real limiter

Here's the mechanism, and it's worth understanding because it changes how you'd want to train.

CO2 isn't just a waste gas you're trying to get rid of. It plays an active role in getting oxygen out of your blood and into your muscles, through what's called the Bohr effect: rising CO2 in your tissues signals your red blood cells to release oxygen where it's needed. Low CO2 tolerance means your body panics at CO2 levels that are actually normal and useful, and it reacts by making you breathe harder and faster.

That's the trap. Heavier, faster breathing raises your heart rate. A higher heart rate burns through your energy systems faster. So the "I need more air" response that feels like it's helping you push harder is often the exact thing making you gas out sooner, whether that's in a 3-minute AMRAP or a 40-minute endurance piece. If you've ever felt like your breathing spiraled out of control before your muscles actually gave out, this is usually why.

Building CO2 tolerance means your body stays calm at higher CO2 levels, so you don't trigger that panic-breathing response as early. Same effort, less panic, more control.

Habit one: breathe through your nose, most of the time

The simplest lever, and the one both the book and the podcast lead with, is nasal breathing. Your nose filters, warms, and humidifies air before it hits your lungs, and nasal breathing naturally slows your breathing rate, which keeps CO2 from clearing out too fast.

The goal isn't to nasal-breathe through every single rep of a max-effort workout, that's not realistic and not the point. It's making nasal breathing your default for daily life and lower-intensity training (easy runs, warm-ups, walking, most of your day), so your baseline CO2 tolerance goes up. The higher you build that baseline, the more capacity you have before you're forced into mouth breathing when things do get hard.

Habit two: train CO2 tolerance directly

This is the part that's actually trainable, and it doesn't need equipment or a scheduled session. Two ways to work on it:

Rhythmic breathing, anytime during the day. Inhale for about 4 seconds, exhale for about 6, so the exhale is noticeably longer than the inhale. On the inhale, don't fill your lungs all the way, aim for roughly half your normal capacity. The point isn't to breathe "deeper," it's to let CO2 build up slightly and get your body used to sitting with it instead of reacting to it. You can do this at your desk, riding the motorbike, waiting at the Angkor Market cashier queue, before bed, anywhere. It's a rehearsal for staying calm under CO2, not a workout.

Breath holds during warm-up. Before training, work some breath-holding into your warm-up, a controlled hold after a normal exhale, then continue moving. This primes the same response: you're deliberately exposing your body to rising CO2 in a low-stakes setting so it's less reactive when CO2 climbs for real once the workout starts.

Neither of these needs to be a big production. The value comes from repetition, not from any single session.

The benefits don't stop at the workout

Nasal breathing and CO2 tolerance aren't just a performance hack, they show up elsewhere too:

  • Sleep quality. Nasal breathing at night is linked to fewer disruptions and better recovery, since mouth breathing during sleep is associated with snoring and lighter, more fragmented sleep.
  • Stress and focus. Slower, CO2-tolerant breathing patterns are the same ones used in most calming and focus techniques, for good reason: your breathing rate and your nervous system state are directly linked.
  • General resilience. Filtering and humidifying air through your nose instead of your mouth means fewer irritants reaching your lungs day to day.

Where to go deeper

If this clicked for you, both sources are worth your time:

  • Breath: The New Science of a Lost Art by James Nestor, book details here. It goes deep into the research and history behind all of this, more than any blog post can cover.
  • The Aerobic Edge podcast episode, linked above, is a good listen if you want the training-specific angle in under an hour.

Try the rhythmic breathing pattern for a week, even just a few minutes a day away from the gym. It's low effort, and it's the kind of thing that quietly pays off once you're mid-workout and your breathing wants to spiral but doesn't.

Lukas

Lukas — Founder, CrossFit Angkor

Lukas has been in sports his whole life, the last 10+ years specifically in CrossFit, obstacle course racing, and hybrid fitness. He's competed in competitions and races across four continents, and geeks out about improving health and optimizing human performance.